Draft submission to Treasury on proposed Living Standards Framework


Submission to New Zealand’s Treasury on the Proposed Living Standards Dashboard

Economic Development New Zealand (EDNZ) thanks the Treasury for the opportunity to comment on its pursuit of a Living Standards Framework.

Whilst EDNZ represents economic development practitioners throughout New Zealand it is very much of the view that economic well-being is inseparable from social, environmental and cultural well-being.  It is that view which motivates EDNZ to respond to your request for feedback on the proposed well-being indicators reflected in the proposed living standards dashboard.

Foremost in that feedback is our appreciation of the Treasury’s journey towards a living standards framework.  The somewhat hackneyed, but all too true phrase, ‘what gets measured, gets done’ is an indication of how important this stream of work is for government, NZ and all New Zealanders. We encourage you to continue the journey which is constructively changing the way we align, assess and account for well-being within New Zealand.

Alignment:

EDNZ is firmly of the view that whatever measures are chosen to assess and account for well-being within New Zealand they must be aligned with international best practice.  The benchmarking opportunity that this offers NZ and the contribution it makes to the international community should not be missed.

The Treasury’s decision therefore to adopt three of the four capital stocks and many of the measures used by the OECD is very much supported.  Wherever possible it would be valued if the dashboard also reflected the ‘intent’ of the Sustainable Development Goals also (which we note the Treasury has done by adding ‘social connections’ to the dashboard.  We look forward to seeing Cultural capital added to the stocks in the future.

As an organisation that represents many local and regional agencies we encourage the Treasury to consider how it might encourage local and regional agencies to adopt indicators from the dashboard to assess, and account for, their respective investment in the well-beings.  This will generate a welcomed vertical alignment, in addition to the horizontal alignment that the Treasury is reaching for.

Assessment:

EDNZ also supports the ‘sustainability’ built in to the dashboard with both current and future indicators of well-being.  We ask that the Treasury gives consideration to including one or two resilience indicators in the dashboard as well, thereby allowing NZ to assess not just our ongoing well-being but our ability to respond rapidly and appropriately in the event of economic, social and natural disaster.

Current domains of wellbeing

EDNZ understands that the Treasury is seeking feedback on the proposed domains of wellbeing.

In a bid to forge greater alignment between the indicators within the OECD we would encourage the Treasury to consider the following:

·         Subjective well-being (unless of course this OECD measure has been repackaged in NZ as Self and aspirations?).

·         Work-life balance (unless this OECD measure has been repackaged as ‘Leisure and recreation’?)

Capital Stocks and current well-being indicators

EDNZ understands that the Treasury is seeking feedback on the proposed capital stocks and current well-being indicators.

There are a number of indicators that EDNZ believes to be fundamental to measurement of well-being within NZ that are not included in either the current or future indicator framework.

They are as follows:

·         Household debt

·         Security of income

·         Investment in R & D

·         Intellectual property assets

·         Child abuse/poverty

·         Number of suicide events

·         Migrants subjective well-being

We would ask that the Treasury consider inserting these measures as new indicators on the dashboard.

A planned review

EDNZ supports the intention to review the effectiveness of the dashboard at the earliest opportunity.

Finally, EDNZ congratulates the Treasury on this stream of work, its potential impact cannot be under-estimated.  We welcome the opportunity to discuss any aspect of this submission with the Treasury at any time.

_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

About EDNZ

EDNZ is a national not for profit that empowers and enables individuals and organisations either practicing, or associated with, economic development across New Zealand.

Membership of EDNZ is the hallmark of Professional Expertise and Integrity within the economic development profession and is open to any individual or organisation working in, or associated with, Economic Development.

EDNZ enables and empowers its members through a number of services including:

·         An economic development jobs board

·         The latest domestic and international ED news

·         Policy and research

·         A Best Practice resource

·         Tools and Tips

·         An annual conference

·         Networking opportunities at a regional and national level

·         Weekly e.newsletter on hot topics in ED

·         Annual Awards that celebrate excellence

·         A code of ethics which sets members apart

To learn more about EDNZ simply follow this link …